Europa League: He Makes Wrong Decisions – Paul Scholes Slams Man United Star Despite Win
Manchester United secured a crucial victory in the UEFA Europa League group stage on Thursday night, but the post-match discussions were far from celebratory for every player. While the result was a positive one for Erik ten Hag’s side, club legend Paul Scholes didn’t shy away from expressing his discontent with the performance of one particular Red Devils star.
The former midfielder, now a pundit for BT Sport, had some stinging criticism following United’s 2-1 victory, accusing the unnamed player of consistently making poor decisions in crucial moments. According to Scholes, while the scoreline might suggest a competent outing, the underlying issues with certain individuals on the pitch continue to hinder United’s overall development and consistency.
A Much-Needed Win, But Not Without Flaws
United came into the game under pressure, having faced a string of underwhelming performances across competitions. A win in Europe was necessary to boost morale and maintain their chances of topping the group. The match started brightly, with United asserting early dominance and creating a flurry of chances. Goals from Bruno Fernandes and Rasmus Højlund gave United a comfortable lead before the opposition managed to pull one back late in the second half.
Despite the win, the team’s performance lacked cohesion in certain areas—particularly in midfield and defense. It was during his post-match analysis that Paul Scholes took the opportunity to address what he sees as a persistent problem for the club.
Scholes’ Scathing Assessment
Paul Scholes did not name the player immediately but went into detail about the traits that have been problematic.
“He’s got quality, there’s no doubt about that,” Scholes began. “But quality without decision-making is pointless at this level. Time and again he picks the wrong option—whether it’s passing when he should run, or shooting when he should look for a teammate.”
Scholes continued: “You can’t keep excusing these moments. We’re not talking about a youngster who’s learning the game. This is someone who’s played at the highest level, in the Premier League, in Europe. You expect better, and frankly, it’s costing the team.”
Eventually, it became apparent that Scholes was referring to Antony, United’s Brazilian winger who arrived from Ajax for a hefty fee in 2022. Antony’s time at Manchester United has been mixed, showing flashes of brilliance but often criticized for being too predictable and lacking end product.
Antony Under the Microscope
The criticism of Antony isn’t new. The Brazilian international has faced scrutiny for his tendency to cut inside onto his favored left foot and attempt ambitious shots rather than involving teammates or seeking a smarter solution. Against lesser opposition, these moments might be overlooked. But in tighter contests, such decisions can be the difference between victory and defeat.
In the Europa League fixture, Antony found himself in promising positions multiple times but failed to convert or assist, often opting for low-percentage plays. This was the focus of Scholes’ frustration.
“He’s trying too hard to be the highlight, to have the moment. But football is a team game,” Scholes remarked. “Look at Bruno, Casemiro, even young Garnacho—they’re making decisions that benefit the whole squad. Antony has to mature quickly, or he’ll find himself left behind.”
Fans Echo the Sentiment
Scholes isn’t alone in his evaluation. Many fans took to social media during and after the match to voice their own concerns about Antony’s lack of growth since his debut season.
One supporter tweeted: “It’s been over a year and Antony still hasn’t learned when to pass. It’s frustrating to watch.” Another posted: “He’s got the flair, but we need effectiveness. We need assists, goals, or at least progressive play. Right now, we’re not getting that.”
While some defended Antony, pointing to his pressing and work rate off the ball, even they conceded that his decision-making in the final third needs urgent improvement.
Ten Hag’s Dilemma
The scrutiny on Antony places manager Erik ten Hag in a difficult position. Having worked with Antony at Ajax, Ten Hag was instrumental in bringing him to Old Trafford. There’s an added pressure on the Dutchman to get the best out of his former pupil, especially given the £85 million transfer fee United paid.
Ten Hag has publicly backed Antony on several occasions, praising his mentality and tactical discipline. However, the manager is also under increasing pressure to deliver results. With young talents like Amad Diallo and Facundo Pellistri waiting for more minutes, and Jadon Sancho’s exile continuing, the right-wing role remains a hot topic of discussion.
Will Ten Hag continue to show faith in Antony, or will he explore other options to spark more dynamism on that flank?
What Needs to Change?
For Antony, the message is clear. Talent alone won’t secure a long-term spot at a club with Manchester United’s ambitions. He must improve his reading of the game, trust his teammates more, and become less predictable. Being flashy isn’t inherently bad, especially at a club that historically embraced flair players, but that flair has to translate into tangible contributions—goals, assists, or at least creating space and opportunities for others.
Improving his right foot, diversifying his runs, and making quicker decisions in transition are all areas that Antony needs to work on. If he does, he can still become the player Ten Hag envisioned when he brought him over from the Eredivisie.
A Glimmer of Hope?
Despite the criticism, it’s worth noting that Antony has the raw tools to succeed. He’s quick, technically gifted, and unafraid to take on defenders. The challenge lies in refining those attributes into something consistent and efficient. United’s coaching staff will be vital in this process, but so will the player’s willingness to adapt and learn.
Scholes’ words, while harsh, may serve as a wake-up call. Many former United greats have faced criticism early in their careers, only to grow into legends of the club. The path is still open for Antony—if he’s ready to walk it with humility and hard work.
Final Thoughts
Manchester United’s victory in the Europa League was a step in the right direction, but as Paul Scholes rightly pointed out, individual performances still raise concern. The team is in a transitional phase, and every player must be held accountable for their contributions—or lack thereof.
Antony is still young and has time on his side, but patience at Old Trafford is wearing thin. The coming months will be critical in determining whether he can adapt and thrive, or if he’ll become yet another big-money signing that failed to meet expectations.
—
Would you like a shorter summary version of this article too?
Leave a Reply