Man United’s Strongest XI Featuring Casemiro, Højlund and Fernandes That Could Face Tottenham
As Manchester United prepare to face Tottenham Hotspur in one of the most pivotal fixtures of their 2024/25 season, all eyes are on how Erik ten Hag—or potentially his successor—will set up the Red Devils against a Spurs side that has been both dynamic and dangerous under Ange Postecoglou. With both sides fighting for European qualification and momentum heading into the final stretch, this encounter at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium is not just about points—it’s about pride, future direction, and tactical evolution.
For United, the challenge lies in fielding their strongest available XI, and balancing a squad that has been plagued by injuries and inconsistencies with star power that still offers moments of brilliance. In this analysis, we construct Manchester United’s strongest possible starting lineup featuring Casemiro, Rasmus Højlund, and Bruno Fernandes, along with other core players who could rise to the occasion.
—
Formation: 4-2-3-1
The 4-2-3-1 remains United’s most familiar and balanced system under Ten Hag. It offers structure in midfield, natural width, and enough fluidity to accommodate key attacking talents. This setup allows Casemiro to shield the defence, Bruno to dictate from central attacking areas, and Højlund to lead the line with support from the flanks.
Let’s break down the strongest possible XI for Manchester United.
—
Goalkeeper: André Onana
Despite a rocky start to his debut season, André Onana has grown in confidence and command. His shot-stopping and ball-playing abilities have been crucial in United’s progression through the Europa League and key league fixtures. Against Tottenham, his distribution under pressure and ability to play out from the back will be vital against a team that presses high and aggressively.
Key Strengths: Passing range, reflexes, calmness in possession
—
Right-Back: Diogo Dalot
With Aaron Wan-Bissaka more defensive-minded and Tyrell Malacia still recovering, Diogo Dalot is a guaranteed starter. The Portuguese full-back has improved defensively while still offering a forward threat. His overlapping runs and ability to tuck into midfield when needed provide United with tactical flexibility.
Key Strengths: Positioning, crossing, tactical awareness
—
Centre-Backs: Raphael Varane and Lisandro Martínez
Raphael Varane, when fit, remains United’s most reliable centre-back. His experience, calmness, and reading of the game are unmatched in the squad. Alongside him, Lisandro Martínez, assuming fitness, adds aggression, left-footed balance, and precise ball progression.
Varane: Aerial dominance, positional sense
Martínez: Tackling, passing under pressure
This pairing offers both steel and style—essential when facing Tottenham’s pacey frontline including Son Heung-min and Dejan Kulusevski.
—
Left-Back: Luke Shaw
If fit, Luke Shaw is an automatic pick. His ability to defend and contribute to the attack makes him one of the most complete full-backs in the Premier League. He is especially important in matches like this where width and support for wide attackers can pin back Tottenham’s inverted full-backs.
Key Strengths: Crossing, one-on-one defending, link-up play
—
Central Midfield Pivot: Casemiro and Kobbie Mainoo
In the double pivot, Casemiro provides the experience and defensive protection, while Kobbie Mainoo adds mobility, dribbling, and forward thrust.
Casemiro: Interceptions, leadership, transitional fouls
Mainoo: Ball carrying, composure, passing through the lines
Mainoo’s emergence has been one of the bright spots of United’s season. He offers the perfect partner to Casemiro, giving United a balance of youth and experience. Their chemistry will be vital in controlling Spurs’ midfield trio and stopping Maddison from influencing the game.
—
Attacking Midfield Trio
Right Wing: Alejandro Garnacho
Though naturally a left-sided forward, Garnacho has shown his adaptability playing on the right. His directness, pace, and ability to cut in and shoot add unpredictability to United’s attacks. He can also track back, which will be crucial against Tottenham’s full-backs.
Key Strengths: Dribbling, acceleration, flair
Central Attacking Midfield: Bruno Fernandes (C)
Bruno Fernandes is the heartbeat of this United side. When he plays well, the team clicks. As captain, he sets the tempo and leads the press from the front. Against Spurs, Bruno’s role in finding gaps between the lines and supplying Højlund will be critical.
Key Strengths: Vision, pressing, chance creation
Left Wing: Marcus Rashford
Rashford’s pace and goal threat from the left make him a constant danger. He thrives in transition, which suits the way United are expected to play against Tottenham’s high line. He’ll look to exploit the space behind Pedro Porro and cut inside to shoot or create.
Key Strengths: Finishing, movement, long-range shooting
—
Striker: Rasmus Højlund
Leading the line is Rasmus Højlund, who has grown into the role with each passing game. His work rate, movement off the ball, and strength in duels make him a menace for defenders. He also links well with Bruno and the wingers, often dropping deep to drag centre-backs out of position.
Against Tottenham’s sometimes shaky central defence, Højlund’s physical presence and aerial threat could prove decisive.
Key Strengths: Hold-up play, intelligent runs, finishing
—
Bench Options
A strong XI must also be supported by a capable bench. Here are key substitutes likely to feature:
Altay Bayındır – Backup goalkeeper
Harry Maguire – Defensive cover
Christian Eriksen – Midfield creativity late on
Scott McTominay – Energy and physicality in midfield
Amad Diallo – Right wing option
Facundo Pellistri – Late-game pace injection
Anthony Martial – If fit, a forward option
Jonny Evans – Experience and aerial defence if defending a lead
—
Tactical Outlook
Against Tottenham’s high press and attacking philosophy, United’s strongest XI needs to:
1. Control transitions – Casemiro and Mainoo must stay compact and cut off passing lanes.
2. Exploit wide areas – Rashford and Garnacho can find joy behind Spurs’ high defensive line.
3. Stay compact defensively – With Varane and Martínez back, United can afford to press higher without exposing their back line.
4. Set pieces and moments – Bruno Fernandes’ delivery and long-range efforts could turn the game on its head in tight moments.
—
Final Thoughts
This XI represents Manchester United’s best blend of experience, youth, and attacking potential. With Fernandes leading the team, Casemiro anchoring the midfield, and Højlund spearheading the attack, this setup offers tactical flexibility, counter-attacking danger, and enough midfield control to challenge a team like Tottenham.
The biggest question heading into the match may not be the talent on the pitch—but whether Ten Hag (or any potential incoming manager) can extract the full potential from this lineup. Against an aggressive Spurs side, United’s strongest XI must not only play to their strengths but show composure, unity, and tactical intelligence.
This clash may
ultimately decide more than just points—it could signal whether this Manchester United team is finally ready to evolve or due for another summer of serious change.
Leave a Reply