Manchester City’s Transfer Challenges: Two Unattainable Targets for Next Season
Manchester City has faced challenges in securing certain midfield targets for the upcoming season. Crystal Palace’s Adam Wharton is reportedly unavailable for a January move, as Palace is determined to retain him amid their current league standing. Similarly, Atalanta’s Ederson is considered unattainable, with the Italian club unwilling to part with the Brazilian midfielder during the winter transfer window. These developments have prompted City to explore alternative options to strengthen their midfield.
Manchester City, one of the most dominant clubs in European football, is known for its meticulous transfer strategies and ability to attract world-class talent. Under Pep Guardiola, the club has built an era of sustained success, winning multiple Premier League titles, domestic trophies, and finally clinching the UEFA Champions League. However, even with their financial strength and sporting appeal, City sometimes face difficulties in securing certain targets.
As the club prepares for next season, two midfielders, Adam Wharton (Crystal Palace) and Ederson (Atalanta), have emerged as prime targets. However, both players are currently deemed unattainable due to their clubs’ reluctance to sell and the players’ contractual situations. This article explores why these two midfielders are essential to City’s plans, why their transfers are challenging, and what alternatives Guardiola might consider.
—
Why Manchester City Needs Midfield Reinforcements
Manchester City’s success is built on its fluid, possession-based style, which requires technically gifted and intelligent midfielders. Over the years, Guardiola has developed a midfield core featuring Kevin De Bruyne, Rodri, Bernardo Silva, and Phil Foden. However, the squad is aging, and injuries have exposed vulnerabilities in City’s depth.
1. Kevin De Bruyne’s Age and Injury Record
De Bruyne remains one of the best playmakers in the world, but at 32, he has suffered frequent injuries in recent seasons. His absence earlier in the 2023-24 season highlighted City’s struggles in breaking down deep defensive blocks. Finding a successor or rotational partner is crucial.
2. Rodri’s Dependence in Defensive Midfield
Rodri has been indispensable in City’s system, but Guardiola lacks a direct backup for him. Without the Spanish midfielder, City has looked vulnerable in defensive transitions, evidenced by their struggles during his suspensions.
3. Bernardo Silva’s Uncertain Future
The Portuguese maestro has been linked with a move away in recent windows, with clubs from Saudi Arabia, Barcelona, and PSG showing interest. If Silva departs, City will need a technically gifted midfielder to replace his ball progression and pressing ability.
With these concerns, City has targeted midfielders Adam Wharton and Ederson to bolster their squad. However, acquiring them has proven difficult.
—
Adam Wharton – The Rising English Midfield Star
Why City Wants Him
Adam Wharton, a young English midfielder playing for Crystal Palace, has emerged as one of the most exciting talents in the Premier League. At just 19 years old, he has demonstrated excellent composure, passing range, and defensive intelligence.
Deep-Lying Playmaker: Wharton is comfortable in a double pivot or as a lone No. 6, making him an ideal long-term backup or alternative to Rodri.
Progressive Passing: His ability to break lines with incisive passes fits City’s style of quick transitions and build-up play.
Defensive Intelligence: Unlike many young midfielders, Wharton already has a strong sense of positioning and defensive responsibilities.
Why He Is Unattainable
Despite City’s interest, Crystal Palace has made it clear that they will not sell Wharton next season. Several factors contribute to this stance:
1. Palace’s Reliance on Him
With veteran midfielders like Cheick Doucouré and Jeffrey Schlupp facing injury concerns, Wharton has become an integral part of Palace’s midfield setup. Selling him now would weaken their squad significantly.
2. Long-Term Contract
Palace recently extended Wharton’s contract, meaning they hold the power in negotiations. Any potential sale would require a massive transfer fee, which City may not be willing to pay.
3. English Premium & Homegrown Quota
English clubs often demand higher fees for young domestic talents. Wharton’s price tag could easily exceed £60 million, making negotiations complicated.
Given these hurdles, City may need to look at other young English midfielders, such as Jacob Ramsey (Aston Villa) or Kobbie Mainoo (Manchester United), though both would also be difficult to sign.
—
Ederson – Atalanta’s Dynamic Brazilian Midfielder
Why City Wants Him
Ederson, the Atalanta midfielder, has caught City’s attention due to his well-rounded skill set. The 24-year-old Brazilian is a perfect blend of defensive resilience and attacking flair.
Defensive Solidity: Strong in tackles and interceptions, Ederson can play as a defensive midfielder alongside Rodri or in a more advanced role.
Physical Presence: At 6 feet tall, he offers aerial strength, which is crucial in both defensive and attacking set pieces.
Work Rate & Versatility: His high pressing ability and endurance fit Guardiola’s intense playing style.
Why He Is Unattainable
Despite City’s interest, Atalanta has no intention of selling Ederson next season. The reasons include:
1. Atalanta’s Ambitions
Atalanta has been performing well in Serie A and European competitions, and losing Ederson would weaken their midfield significantly. The club is targeting Champions League qualification, making his sale unlikely.
2. Key Player in Gian Piero Gasperini’s System
Ederson has become a crucial part of Gasperini’s high-pressing system, making him irreplaceable in their setup. Unlike some clubs willing to sell for the right price, Atalanta has a history of keeping key players unless an exceptional offer is made.
3. No Active Release Clause
Unlike some players with fixed buyout clauses, Ederson does not have one, meaning Atalanta can set a high asking price. Reports suggest they would demand at least €60-70 million, making negotiations tough.
As a result, City may shift focus to other midfielders such as Bruno Guimarães (Newcastle), João Neves (Benfica), or Frenkie de Jong (Barcelona), though each comes with its own challenges.
—
What’s Next for Manchester City?
Since both Wharton and Ederson appear unattainable, Guardiola and the club’s sporting director, Txiki Begiristain, must explore alternative options. Potential approaches include:
1. Pursuing Other Midfielders
City could look at alternative targets in Spain, Germany, or Portugal. Midfielders like Martin Zubimendi (Real Sociedad), Amadou Onana (Everton), or Florentino Luís (Benfica) could be considered.
2. Promoting from the Academy
Manchester City’s academy has produced excellent midfielders like James McAtee and Oscar Bobb. Guardiola might integrate them instead of spending heavily on new signings.
3. Waiting Until the Winter Transfer Window
If Wharton or Ederson become available in January 2026, City could reassess their options and attempt to sign them later.
—
Conclusion
Manchester City’s search for midfield reinforcements has been met with challenges, as both Adam Wharton and Ederson appear unattainable for next season. Palace and Atalanta are unwilling to sell their key midfielders, making negotiations difficult. Despite City’s financial strength and sporting appeal, certain transfers remain out of reach due to club ambitions, contract situations, and transfer fees.
With Guardiola’s long-term vision in mind, City must now explore alternative targets, promote young talents, or reconsider their approach in future windows. While these setbacks may be frustrating, the club’s scouting network and strategic planning will ensure they remain competitive in the coming seasons.
Leave a Reply