How Maarten Lammens Could Challenge Onana for Manchester United’s No.1 Spot
When Maarten Lammens stepped out under the floodlights at Old Trafford for his Premier League debut against Sunderland, few outside Belgium truly knew what to expect. The 21-year-old goalkeeper, signed quietly from Club Brugge earlier this year, was handed a surprise start by Rúben Amorim in place of André Onana. What followed was a calm, composed, and mature display that may have quietly altered the trajectory of Manchester United’s goalkeeping department.
In a match defined by composure and control rather than chaos and panic, Lammens looked every inch the modern goalkeeper — confident with the ball at his feet, assertive in his area, and unflustered by the occasion. United’s 2–0 victory, secured by goals from Mason Mount and Benjamin Šeško, wasn’t just a vital three points; it was also the night Maarten Lammens announced himself to Old Trafford.
A Calculated Gamble from Amorim
Rúben Amorim’s decision to start Lammens over Onana surprised many. The Cameroonian, though error-prone at times, has been United’s undisputed No.1 since his arrival from Inter Milan. Yet, Amorim’s tactical philosophy — which emphasizes structure, calm distribution, and positional bravery — demands a goalkeeper who functions as more than a shot-stopper.
Amorim hinted at his reasoning in his post-match comments:
> “We need competition in every position. Maarten has trained well, he understands how we build from the back, and tonight was his moment to show it. He earned this chance.”
That final sentence was telling. Lammens wasn’t simply rotated for rest or fitness reasons; he was rewarded for form and tactical fit. In Amorim’s system, every player must serve the collective — and Lammens’ profile aligns almost perfectly with the manager’s demands.
Who Is Maarten Lammens?
Born in Ghent, Belgium, Maarten Lammens joined Club Brugge’s academy at the age of 10. From the outset, he was known for his maturity and calm under pressure. Coaches described him as a “thinking goalkeeper,” someone who analyzed patterns of play and anticipated danger rather than reacting to it.
Standing at 6ft 3in, Lammens combines traditional goalkeeping fundamentals with modern technical ability. At Brugge, he rose through the ranks alongside current stars like Charles De Ketelaere and Antonio Nusa, before eventually becoming second choice behind Simon Mignolet.
United’s scouts, led by Luke Fedorenko (who is now leaving the club to join a major football agency), identified Lammens as a long-term project — a goalkeeper who could develop under the right structure and eventually challenge Onana. His €6 million move last summer was viewed as low-risk but potentially high reward.
Composure Beyond His Years
What stood out most during Lammens’ debut wasn’t a string of spectacular saves but his control of the game’s tempo. Sunderland pressed aggressively, trying to force United into errors in their own half. Yet Lammens remained calm, consistently finding Kobbie Mainoo or Diogo Dalot with precise passes under pressure.
At one point in the first half, with two Sunderland forwards closing him down, he feigned a clearance before slipping a delicate pass through the middle to Mount — triggering a counterattack that led to Šeško’s first chance of the night. It was a moment of composure that embodied Amorim’s footballing ideals.
His passing accuracy (92%) was the highest of any player on the pitch. More impressively, he completed seven progressive passes into midfield — an area where Onana has occasionally struggled this season under pressure.
Learning from Onana
To be clear, André Onana remains United’s first-choice goalkeeper, and rightly so. The Cameroonian is vastly experienced, a Champions League finalist, and one of the best distributors in world football when confident. But confidence has been the issue.
Onana’s inconsistent start to the season — marked by high-profile mistakes against Brentford and Arsenal — opened the door for Amorim to explore alternatives. Lammens’ performance doesn’t necessarily threaten Onana’s position immediately, but it introduces healthy competition that could elevate both goalkeepers.
Interestingly, those close to Carrington describe their relationship as “mutually respectful.” Onana has reportedly taken on a mentoring role, guiding Lammens through the adaptation process and encouraging him to be vocal in training. Amorim, who values harmony and internal competition, has praised both for their professionalism.
> “They push each other — and that’s what I want,” the United boss said after the Sunderland match. “We can’t rely on one goalkeeper; we need two ready for every challenge.”
Why Amorim’s System Favours Lammens
Rúben Amorim’s tactical system — inspired by his Sporting CP model — requires the goalkeeper to act as the first playmaker. United build in a 3–2–5 structure in possession, with the goalkeeper forming part of the first line of build-up alongside the centre-backs.
Here’s where Lammens excels. His natural calmness, two-footedness, and quick decision-making make him ideal for this system. He doesn’t just clear danger — he constructs play.
Unlike Onana, who often takes risks with long diagonal passes, Lammens prefers short, precise connections that draw opponents in before exploiting the space behind them. It’s a more measured, almost chess-like approach — one that mirrors Amorim’s emphasis on control over chaos.
That said, Amorim’s confidence in using a 21-year-old debutant in a Premier League game shows his long-term vision. He is shaping a squad where every position has depth, competition, and tactical flexibility — and Lammens’ attributes fit that blueprint perfectly.
The Mentality to Thrive
A recurring theme in reports from Belgium about Lammens is his mentality. At Club Brugge, he was known for his discipline and analytical mindset. He’d often spend hours after training reviewing match footage, not of himself, but of top goalkeepers like Ederson and Ter Stegen, studying their positioning and decision-making.
That intellectual curiosity has impressed United’s goalkeeping coaches. One staff member reportedly described him as “a student of the game — quiet, focused, and obsessed with details.”
Amorim’s staff value that kind of approach. They’ve emphasized a culture of tactical intelligence and self-improvement, and Lammens seems to embody it. In a squad where emotional volatility has sometimes undermined progress, his calm demeanor provides balance.
What the Future Could Hold
So, could Maarten Lammens genuinely challenge Onana for the No.1 spot? Not immediately — but it’s not out of the question.
If he continues to perform consistently in cup matches and occasional league starts, Amorim could find himself with a legitimate selection dilemma by January. United face a congested schedule, including the FA Cup and European fixtures, and Lammens is expected to start in some of those games.
His progress could also influence United’s long-term planning. At 21, Lammens is young enough to grow with the team being built around Mainoo, Garnacho, and Šeško. If he can continue to develop his command of the box and physical presence — areas where Onana still holds the edge — the Belgian could realistically become United’s future No.1.
Reactions and Praise
Pundits were quick to praise Lammens’ debut. Former United goalkeeper Peter Schmeichel, speaking on Sky Sports, said:
> “It’s rare to see a young keeper so composed on his debut. He didn’t just save shots; he controlled the rhythm. That’s a big step in modern goalkeeping.”
Even Amorim, who typically downplays individual praise, couldn’t resist:
> “For Maarten, it’s the beginning. He trained for this moment, and he delivered. Now he has to stay humble and keep learning.”
Lammens, for his part, remained characteristically grounded:
> “It’s a dream to play for this club. I’ve learned a lot from André and the staff, and I just want to keep improving. Every game, every session — that’s how I’ll grow.”
Conclusion
Maarten Lammens’ Premier League debut may not make global headlines, but it could prove quietly significant in Manchester United’s long-term rebuild. His performance against Sunderland showcased a goalkeeper perfectly suited to Rúben Amorim’s philosophy: intelligent, composed, and tactically disciplined.
While André Onana remains United’s first choice, Lammens’ emergence introduces something United have lacked for years — genuine competition between two stylistically compatible goalkeepers. It keeps Onana sharp, offers Amorim flexibility, and ensures the future of the position is in safe hands.
For now, Lammens will bide his time, continue to learn, and wait for more opportunities. But if his debut is any indication, Manchester United may have quietly found their next great goalkeeper — one who could define the next era at Old Trafford with calm authority rather than noise.
Leave a Reply