Rúben Amorim: The Clearest-Headed Coach United Have Had – Proven by the Onana Case
Whenever I say that Rúben Amorim is the clearest-headed coach Manchester United have had in years, I often get pushback. Some fans argue that he’s still unproven at the very top level, others say his tactical philosophy hasn’t yet been fully tested in the unforgiving Premier League. But every now and then, a moment arrives that silences the noise and reveals a manager’s true character. The recent André Onana case is exactly that moment.
—
The Onana Gamble
When Manchester United signed André Onana in 2023, the deal was heralded as a bold step forward. Here was a goalkeeper fresh off a Champions League final with Inter Milan, known for his ball-playing ability and fearlessness. He was supposed to be the missing link, the sweeper-keeper to unlock Erik ten Hag’s vision.
But reality didn’t match expectation. Onana struggled with consistency, committing high-profile errors in both domestic and European competitions. While he had moments of brilliance, his mistakes often overshadowed them. By the end of his first season, his numbers told a sobering story:
102 matches played
24 clean sheets
150 goals conceded
18 errors directly leading to goals
This wasn’t the record of a dependable No.1 at a club aspiring for greatness.
—
Amorim’s Bold Decision
Where previous United managers might have persisted out of stubbornness or sentiment, Amorim made the bold, clear-headed call: Onana would leave on loan to Trabzonspor.
It wasn’t an easy decision. Onana was a high-profile, big-money signing who had only been at the club for a short time. Bench him, and you risk upsetting the dressing room. Keep him, and you continue suffering the consequences of inconsistency. Amorim chose neither. He cut through the noise and did what many feared: he put the needs of the team above reputational baggage.
This was Amorim’s clarity at work. He wasn’t interested in saving face for the boardroom or protecting a player’s ego. He made a footballing decision, plain and simple.
—
Why It Proves His Clarity
The Onana case proves that Amorim isn’t swayed by emotion or pressure. At Manchester United, this is rare. Too often in the post-Ferguson era, managers have clung to players out of hope rather than conviction. David Moyes, Louis van Gaal, José Mourinho, Ole Gunnar Solskjær, and Erik ten Hag all had moments where they failed to act decisively on underperforming players.
Amorim broke that cycle. By letting Onana go, he showed he’s willing to face short-term criticism for long-term gain. Fans may argue, pundits may sneer, but Amorim demonstrated that he has a vision — and he won’t let sentiment cloud it.
—
Managing the Dressing Room
Another reason this decision underlines Amorim’s clarity is the message it sends inside the dressing room. United’s squad has often been accused of complacency. Big contracts, star reputations, and a lack of accountability created an environment where players believed underperformance carried no real consequences.
By moving Onana on loan, Amorim sent a stark warning: no one is untouchable. If a marquee signing can be shown the door, anyone can. This restores discipline and accountability, something United have lacked for years. For the younger players especially, it sets the tone: play well, or someone else will take your place.
—
Not Just About Onana
To some, this case is only about one goalkeeper. But it’s much bigger. It’s about Amorim imposing a new culture. Previous managers often bent under the weight of United’s politics: boardroom interference, fan pressure, and media scrutiny. Amorim, however, is proving that he won’t compromise his principles.
He looked at the evidence: a goalkeeper who couldn’t command his box, who struggled with consistency, and whose errors directly cost United points. Then he acted decisively. That’s what clear-headed leadership looks like.
—
The Fans’ Reaction
Unsurprisingly, fans were split. Some celebrated Onana’s exit, pointing to his catalogue of mistakes. Others felt sympathy, arguing he wasn’t given enough time behind a shaky defence. But amid the debate, one truth stood out: Amorim’s decision made people sit up and take notice.
For the first time in years, it felt like a Manchester United manager wasn’t dithering. He wasn’t waiting for things to magically improve. He wasn’t pandering to the hierarchy. He was acting decisively, even ruthlessly, in pursuit of a higher standard.
—
Comparing Amorim to His Predecessors
Consider the contrast. Ten Hag, who brought Onana in, stuck by him despite glaring mistakes. Mourinho famously clashed with players but often escalated situations into personal feuds. Ole was too soft, clinging to players like Harry Maguire and Anthony Martial long after they had proven inconsistent.
Amorim’s clarity is different. It isn’t about personal vendettas or blind loyalty. It’s about cold, rational decision-making. He looked at Onana’s performance, weighed it against the standards required, and acted. Simple, but powerful.
—
A Ripple Effect Across the Club
The ripple effect of Amorim’s clarity could reshape Manchester United. By setting the tone with Onana, he’s sending a message that will reach every corner of the squad: mediocrity will no longer be tolerated. That kind of ruthlessness is what made Sir Alex Ferguson legendary. It’s what United have been missing for more than a decade.
Already, rumours are circulating about other potential exits. Casemiro’s declining influence, Martial’s inconsistency, and even the futures of fringe players are all under review. If Amorim applies the same clarity he showed with Onana, United may finally start shedding deadwood in pursuit of excellence.
—
The Bigger Picture
Of course, Amorim’s clarity will be truly tested by results. It’s one thing to make tough calls; it’s another to back them up with success on the pitch. But even at this early stage, the Onana case reveals something crucial: United finally have a manager who can separate emotion from strategy, who can make unpopular decisions in service of the bigger picture.
Fans might argue, rivals might laugh, and pundits might nitpick. But clarity of vision is rare in football, especially at a club as turbulent as Manchester United. Amorim has it — and that could be the foundation for something lasting.
—
Conclusion
Whenever I say Rúben Amorim is the clearest-headed coach Manchester United have had in years, people argue. They question his experience, his tactical approach, his ability to handle the Premier League spotlight. But the André Onana case proves it beyond doubt.
Amorim saw a problem, acted without hesitation, and put the needs of the team first. He wasn’t swayed by sentiment, reputation, or financial baggage. He showed a level of clarity and ruthlessness that United have been crying out for since Sir Alex Ferguson retired.
In moving Onana out, Amorim did more than solve a goalkeeping issue. He drew a line in the sand, signalling the dawn of a new culture at Manchester United — one built on accountability, high standards, and clear-headed leadership.
For the first time in years, United fans can believe that their club is finally being led with purpose. And for that, they have Rúben Amorim to thank.
Leave a Reply